The early demise of tagging

This post if slightly off topic, and more on a general blogging and internet issue – tagging.

Over the last three months, I thought I would listen to the top bloggers, and get right into tagging, just to see what all the fuss is about. I have been diligently tagging my posts in Technorati since then. One of the most popular tags in my posts, given the subject matter, is online banking. The results in Technorati, are nothing short of useless; in fact worse than useless.

Perhaps because I have picked a popular topic, but the degree of spam blogging that Technorati seem to be incapable of eliminating, makes the "online+banking" tag worthless. I have posted the first page from Technorati below. The first post is from the excellent Payment News. Every other link on that page is spam. These are blogs set up by SEO types to get their brand to the top. Well good for Bank of America today, but the credibility of what Technorati is intended to provide is so shot, that no consumers will come to this tag to find you anyway.

This is the email equivalent of spam, and could kill tags unless someone figures it out. Technorati ned to find a way to incorporate intelligence and personal sorting so that I can locate what I want, and my neighbour can find what they want, and so on.

For now, Technorati is the worst of old style marketing.

 Update (22.jun.2006):

Over at Seth's Blog he points out the same issue at FURL.

# In Payments News Payments Strategy 3 days ago Susannah Fox and Jean Beier of the Pew Internet & American Life Project examine consumer usage of…

# Bank of America Online Banking Bank of America online banking In Webtrendz Blog! 4 days ago Bank of America Online Banking Bank of America online banking is available to any customer who currently does business with the bank. Participation in…

# Bank of America Online Banking In Finance And Banking | Online Banking Services 4 days ago Bank of America online banking is available to any customer who currently does business with the bank. Participation in the Bank of America online…

# Get Started with Wells Fargo Online Banking Today! Wells In Webtrendz Blog! 4 days ago Get Started with wells fargo online banking Today! Wells Fargo online banking offers many of the features you would expect a bank to offer. In…

# An Examination of Online Banking in the United Kingdom In Finance And Banking | Online Banking Services 5 days ago In the UK, many banks and building societies are attempting to capture a sizeable percentage of the online banking market share. And it seems that the…

# 7 Tips For Better Online Banking In Finance And Banking | Online Banking Services 6 days ago Banking has never been easier than it is today. Online banking allows you to access you bank at any time of day or night. You can even do this dressed…

# Online banking information In Ing banking information 9 days ago Online banking

# Wachovia online banking information In Ing banking information 9 days ago Wachovia online banking

# Online banking billing information In Low cost 10 days ago Online banking billing

Technorati Tags: , ,

3 thoughts on “The early demise of tagging

  1. Dennis is right – I am not criticising tagging, which is a terribly useful and convenient means to sort through information.

    I _am_ criticising Technorati for not addressing the spam and pollution of tagging within their environment.

    There is such potential for someone and others like them to host a central repository of tags, that co-ordinates users tags, and facilitates like minded people to find useful information.

Comments are closed.