Can an "Internet only" bank work? or ….. Can a branchless bank work?


Great thought provoking discussion going on in the comments, that made me realise it warrants deeper analysis. Except for eBank (run by President Taiichi Matsuo, former LTCB) all other Internet banks had strong parents with deep pockets to establish the online brand or leverage the existing brand (Sony). Although these banks are definitely not modeled after a phone bank, they are marketed strongly in the offline world. And eBank is marketed and operates more like a Paypal. Source: BankerVision: Can an “Internet only” bank work? « Bankwatch James started it off here, and the title outlines the context. First of … Continue reading Can an "Internet only" bank work? or ….. Can a branchless bank work?

NetBanker 2.0: Bank-Anywhere.com launches branch locator mashup


 Jim is 100% right here.  I am surprised that no bank is there yet.  I know of one in the works, that plans to be live this year. Analysis Financial institutions should consider using a similar approach on their websites, either programming the function themselves or outsourcing it to Bank-Anywhere.com or others. Not only is it easier to use, the Ajax-based map looks more sophisticated and up-to-date. It’s important to make a good impression with locator tools since it’s one of the first things a prospective new customer will look at when considering opening an account at your bank. Source: … Continue reading NetBanker 2.0: Bank-Anywhere.com launches branch locator mashup

BAI Online | Investing in the Franchise – Bank of America strategy


Some fascinating insights into the the strategy of Bank of America. A national franchise, vs state by state.  This is s consequential statement given that Bank of America have a similar number of customers as the population of UK – 55 million customers.

McGee: We’ve been running this business, consumer and small business, as a national business for about five years now. The decision that we faced at the time was whether to become a national franchise or, like most of the other large banks, run it market by market, state by state, etc.

Source: BAI Online | Banking Strategies | September/October 2006 | Investing in the Franchise

To Bank of America, strategic clarity is “making a difference for customers” by providing a consistent level of service and responsiveness across the company’s vast coast-to-coast franchise

The quotes just get better and better ….

We also made the decision to run a more integrated business. We’re different from almost anybody you’d compare us to in that our distribution channels — banking centers, online services, call centers, mortgage sales force, etc. — really work with the product groups in an integrated fashion, with the customer in the center. Most of our competitors run those businesses as silos — the card business is run as a silo, the mortgage business, etc. We’ve run a very integrated model for a long time, and that’s also helped us prioritize against the things that mattered for customers and for our teammates.

And this quote is as memorable as any … again remembering how big they are:

Q: How do you reduce complexity on the frontlines? You’ve got so many products, so many different divisions and services. Do you tell your branch people to focus on just a few?

McGee: We have tended to focus on a few products that we think are the most important for customers and drivers of growth. That doesn’t mean that associates don’t do other things. But it’s easier when you give them a context for what’s important for the customers and what’s important for the shareholders.

It wasn’t always popular at the beginning to do that because some associates might have been focused on other things. But, all of us have learned that if you can prioritize and simplify, the entire boat rises. If you try to be everything to everybody, then no one does well.

The ability to develop a laser like focus down to every front line employee, is a strategic advantage.

Q: Who is that single point of accountability?

McGee: We have five people who run our almost 6,000 stores, and four of the five are responsible for the high growth markets and the fifth the community markets, wherever they may be across America. Under each of them are region executives, the people the product groups are really accountable to—to get the right product, the right process and have that mutual accountability.

Five people – 6,000 branches (stores) – wow!  I know banks in with 1,000 branches, and 15 – 20 people responsible, without counting the SVP’s, VP’s, directors, & senior managers who also are involved.

Finally the positive aspect of dynamic tension:

Q: So, the dynamic tension comes in the discussion and give-and-take between the product groups and the regional executives?

McGee: Well, it’s not at all dissimilar to the classic retail market. You take any retailer and they interact with product manufacturers who want shelf space. The retailer has an accountability to put the product in the right space and sell it. But the retailer will hold the manufacturer accountable if the product does not deliver to the specs ordered and at the price point.

We are very much emulating that dynamic tension. It’s very different from having a head of cards who is only thinking about his or her bottom line. We have an integrated team that really has the new and existing customer as the focal point. So in our company, you have to be very good at running your business or area discipline, but you have to be equally good at balancing that with what’s the best thing for our customers in our enterprise.

That’s why you’ve seen a lot of innovation coming from us in the last couple of years, such as Keep the Change, Mortgage Rewards, Business 24/7 and Safe Send. Take Keep the Change, for example. The reason we were able to do that is, first of all, we spend a lot of time talking to customers. One of the things Six Sigma has taught us is to be very disciplined about the voice of the customer.

Relevance to Bankwatch:

The article is worth reading.  Its a standard bearer for how to organise, and implement across a (very) large organisation.  You are probably smaller than Bank of America, so no excuses.

 

 

Continue reading “BAI Online | Investing in the Franchise – Bank of America strategy”

"Japan is driven by consumer demand"


 That simple statement, and the corollary that North America is driven by cost, says a lot about marketing, culture, and the current state of crisis where marketing finds itself in North America.  I don’t see that same crisis in Japan. In the U.S., consumers tend to favor low-cost machines even if they are slightly heavier than other models, noted Douglas Krone, chief executive of Dynamism.com, a company that sells imported technology. Those in the U.S. are driven by business needs, he said, and tight budgets tend to favor inexpensive, but more weighty, laptops. By contrast, Japanese buyers in both the … Continue reading "Japan is driven by consumer demand"

Enterprise Decision Management – Improving Customer Experience with EDM


I can safely say I have lived through all the mistakes and flawed assumptions since the beginning of online banking, when we simplistically spoke of the near future where marketing was as simple as the right message, at the right time, to the right customer. I like James blog because he talks about how we should just do it based on what he calls EDM. Essentially I proposed that using technology like business rules and analytics to improve the moments of decision when interacting with a customer can improve their experience. Targeting, rewarding loyalty, empowering staff and leveraging information are … Continue reading Enterprise Decision Management – Improving Customer Experience with EDM

Integrating the Channels – steps in the evolution


Light but broad piece from Banktech on channel management.  Its a broad based review of the current situation, and the shift to customer centric from product centric.  Nothing new, but good overview. The development of banks’ overall channel strategies has been anything but deliberate. Delivery channels have grown from need and technological advances, and banks’ channel strategies have evolved in response. But now that financial institutions are juggling numerous channels and the multitude of ways in which they touch customers, many banks are actively looking to integrate those delivery channels more strategically. Source: http://www.banktech.com/printableArticle.jhtml;jsessionid=5XLYKAHUPHCO0QSNDLRSKHSCJUNN2JVN?articleID=193402868 Summary: channel development driven by technology … Continue reading Integrating the Channels – steps in the evolution

Finextra: PayPal claims a third of UK adult population


 At first glance I find this statistic unbelievable.  Then the last sentence got me … people are using Paypal to get around bank fees, and that makes sense given the high ethnic population in parts of UK.  Whether its a third or not, it makes sense there is a group sending money abroad using Paypal. Person-to-person payments outfit PayPal says that it now has over 15 million account holders in the UK, representing over a third of the adult population. Paypal says UK growth is being fuelled by sharp increases in online spending and by demand for low-cost remittance services … Continue reading Finextra: PayPal claims a third of UK adult population

BankerVision: Can an “Internet only” bank work?


Great question, that I cannot resist. can an Internet-only bank work? Source: BankerVision: Egg Internet bank So I will leap in to the fray with an answer than might be expected from someone who is bullish on internet banking. I say yes it will work. I say this despite the evidence against.  We have the evidence, mbanx, Wingspan, and possibly Egg.  But let me qualify.  The first two failed because their costs were higher than their revenue. fulfillment costs:  account opening kits cost a lot, and getting them to customers is expensive account opening costs:  accounts opened but many customers … Continue reading BankerVision: Can an “Internet only” bank work?

More on Wal-Mart and their Canadian banking entree


I started to reply to a great comment question to this post on Wal-mart, and realised this deserves a post. The question from Jeff was “Can this in any way be used as an end run around the opposition in the United States?”, and Jeff started it off on his blog here. ______________________________ I have to think it cannot be a co-incidence that Canada and the US are right beside each other. However Canada is tiny (32 million pop) at 10% of the US in population. When I listened to Jane Thompson speak she went out of her way to … Continue reading More on Wal-Mart and their Canadian banking entree

Wal-Mart eyes banking in Canada


 At the Forrester conference in May, I blogged about Wal-Mart trying to get into banking in the US, which has successfully been lobbied into submission. So here comes the Canadian angle. Wal-Mart Canada Corp. is looking to expand into the financial services business, a potentially lucrative growth area as the retailing price war intensifies over food, clothing and other consumer staples. The big-box giant recently hired Trudy Fahie as vice-president of financial services at Wal-Mart Canada, a role created for assessing the retailer’s options in the sector. Ms. Fahie is the former vice-president of financial services for American Express Canada. … Continue reading Wal-Mart eyes banking in Canada